"Note that all dualistic concepts and emotions – even positive ones such as caring, compassion, and wishing others well – are accompanied by grasping at ‘self’. So although positive emotions are good, they still fall short of perfection, which is the primordial wisdom beyond dualistic thinking and emotional sensations. Grasping at positive qualities is nonetheless a stepping-stone to perfection, helping us eventually to loosen the grip of grasping at ‘self’ and to experience sensations of peace and joy. So, transforming from negative to positive, and then from positive to perfection, is the ideal way to move toward buddhahood, or full perfection."
~ Tulku Thondup
Commentary by Jerome:
Today I met a friend who was feeling troubled by her relationship problems. She tried to reaffirm herself positively but felt that this does not resolve the underlying issue. Still she was not feeling happy.
Indeed, being positive is good but not the best. Why is this so? By being positive, one may bring himself out of negative emotions and possibly depression. However, this merely diverts one's attention to another object and covers up the underlying cause of the problem. The true solution is to let go of the underlying grasping (aka attachment to the relationship).
By being positive, there is still "grasping" on to the positive object, which can be any of the 6 sense objects (taste, smell, touch, sights, sounds and thoughts). For instance, one may see a beautiful flower and think: "What a beautiful flower!" This emotion that arises can surely brighten your day but it still involve dualistic thinking (good and bad) and the arising of attachment to the object. In the highest cultivation, we should loosen this grip on ourselves and external objects. We see an object and no thought arises. We feel a soft toy and no thought arises. We rest in a peaceful state, a joyful and natural state that is free from any form of attachment to the 6 sense objects. Please do not mistake this as indifference! It is a clarity of the mind and the ability to see these objects in their natural state (Some people call this emptiness. Empty of secondary thoughts and conceptions. Empty of discriminative thoughts.) These sense objects are fundamentally not good or bad but it is the person experiencing it who labels them. When brought to perfection in this practice we can attain the highest form of cultivation.
Indeed, being positive is good but not the best. Why is this so? By being positive, one may bring himself out of negative emotions and possibly depression. However, this merely diverts one's attention to another object and covers up the underlying cause of the problem. The true solution is to let go of the underlying grasping (aka attachment to the relationship).
By being positive, there is still "grasping" on to the positive object, which can be any of the 6 sense objects (taste, smell, touch, sights, sounds and thoughts). For instance, one may see a beautiful flower and think: "What a beautiful flower!" This emotion that arises can surely brighten your day but it still involve dualistic thinking (good and bad) and the arising of attachment to the object. In the highest cultivation, we should loosen this grip on ourselves and external objects. We see an object and no thought arises. We feel a soft toy and no thought arises. We rest in a peaceful state, a joyful and natural state that is free from any form of attachment to the 6 sense objects. Please do not mistake this as indifference! It is a clarity of the mind and the ability to see these objects in their natural state (Some people call this emptiness. Empty of secondary thoughts and conceptions. Empty of discriminative thoughts.) These sense objects are fundamentally not good or bad but it is the person experiencing it who labels them. When brought to perfection in this practice we can attain the highest form of cultivation.
References: